AIM, the Main Market and PISCES solve different problems. A company seeking substantial new primary capital and a public listing should compare AIM and the Main Market. A private company seeking occasional secondary liquidity for existing shareholders or employees can consider PISCES. A company that is not ready for the disclosure, governance, cost and management demands of any market should remain private and solve the specific capital or liquidity problem another way.
- OverviewAIM, the Main Market and PISCES solve different problems.
- Define the transaction before choosing the marketWrite a one-page transaction brief with the amount of new capital required, shareholders who may sell, intended investor base, acceptable dilution, desired timing, use of proceeds and governance consequences.
- AIM is a public growth market with continuing obligationsAIM is operated by London Stock Exchange for growing companies.
- The Main Market is a regulated-market and listing decisionThe Main Market combines admission to trading on a regulated market with the relevant FCA listing route.
- PISCES is intermittent secondary liquidity for private sharesPISCES, the Private Intermittent Securities and Capital Exchange System, is being tested in an FCA sandbox.
AIM, the Main Market and PISCES solve different problems. A company seeking substantial new primary capital and a public listing should compare AIM and the Main Market. A private company seeking occasional secondary liquidity for existing shareholders or employees can consider PISCES. A company that is not ready for the disclosure, governance, cost and management demands of any market should remain private and solve the specific capital or liquidity problem another way.
The board should decide the objective before selecting a route. New capital, shareholder liquidity, employee retention, acquisition currency, profile and a path for early investors are related but not identical goals. PISCES is not a smaller IPO, and AIM is not simply a cheaper Main Market.
Define the transaction before choosing the market
Write a one-page transaction brief with the amount of new capital required, shareholders who may sell, intended investor base, acceptable dilution, desired timing, use of proceeds and governance consequences. If the objective is employee liquidity, a primary fundraising process may be disproportionate. If the company needs permanent access to public equity, an occasional private trading event may not be enough.
Include the option to do nothing. A private placement, tender offer, structured employee sale, debt facility or later transaction may better match the need. The previous Shoreditch Talk analysis of whether London turns startup density into durable scale explains why progression to a market should be judged by operating durability rather than treated as a ceremonial next stage.
The board should also identify non-negotiable constraints. These include investor rights, founder control, sensitive customer information, audited history, reporting systems, share-plan terms and the time senior management can devote to preparation and continuing obligations.
AIM is a public growth market with continuing obligations
AIM is operated by London Stock Exchange for growing companies. Admission is governed by the AIM Rules for Companies, with later amendments and notices also requiring review. An AIM company must retain a nominated adviser, commonly called a Nomad, which assesses suitability and guides continuing compliance.
An AIM admission can include primary fundraising and secondary sales. It creates publicly traded shares and ongoing disclosure, reporting, governance and market-conduct responsibilities. The absence of a single minimum company size does not mean every smaller company is suitable. Adviser appetite, investor demand, financial controls, management depth and the ability to communicate consistently are practical gates.
The board should budget beyond the admission fee. London Stock Exchange publishes AIM and Main Market fee information, but exchange fees are only one component. Legal, accounting, Nomad, broker, reporting, investor-relations and management costs continue after admission. Model those costs over several years and under a weak trading-liquidity scenario.
The Main Market is a regulated-market and listing decision
The Main Market combines admission to trading on a regulated market with the relevant FCA listing route. The FCA UK Listing Rules for commercial companies cover eligibility for the equity shares commercial companies category, including the requirement for sufficient shares to be in public hands. The FCA sponsor regime requires approved firms to advise and provide specified confirmations for relevant listing work.
For a scale-up, the Main Market may suit a larger transaction, a broader institutional investor objective or a company whose strategy benefits from the regulated-market framework. It also requires systems and board capacity that can support market disclosure, governance, financial reporting and shareholder scrutiny.
The UK's prospectus and admission framework changed in January 2026. The FCA's prospectus and circular submission guidance should be read with current rules and specialist advice. A board paper that relies on a pre-2026 IPO checklist is not a reliable readiness assessment.
PISCES is intermittent secondary liquidity for private shares
PISCES, the Private Intermittent Securities and Capital Exchange System, is being tested in an FCA sandbox. The PISCES sandbox legislation creates a framework for intermittent secondary trading in existing private-company shares. It is not a route for issuing new shares to raise primary capital.
The company can remain private while allowing trading through defined events and participation rules. That can be relevant for employees, founders and early investors seeking controlled liquidity. It also requires decisions about eligible sellers and buyers, disclosures, price formation, trading frequency and the effect of transactions on the shareholder register.
The FCA's PISCES sandbox page says the sandbox runs until June 2030 while operators and companies test the framework. A board should therefore treat PISCES as a live but developing regime, confirm which approved platform can support the proposed event and understand that permanent legislation may differ.
Employee shares need separate tax and plan analysis. HMRC's PISCES employee-share technical note addresses tax-advantaged plans, valuation and readily convertible asset questions. It should not be reduced to a promise that employees can sell without tax or plan consequences.
Compare disclosure and control, not only admission cost
Each route asks the company to share information, but the audience, timing and framework differ. A public company makes continuing market disclosures and publishes financial reports. A PISCES company provides information for intermittent events under the platform's arrangements. Remaining private does not remove disclosure needs because investors, lenders, employees and buyers still conduct due diligence.
Build a disclosure inventory covering financial performance, forecasts, customer concentration, litigation, regulation, cybersecurity, intellectual property, related parties, remuneration and material contracts. Mark what is already supported by a controlled process and what depends on spreadsheets or individual knowledge.
Control also needs precise treatment. Consider voting rights, board composition, pre-emption, new share issuance, acquisitions, executive incentives and takeover exposure. Weighted voting or other structures require advice under the chosen rules. Do not use the word control as a substitute for modelling actual shareholder votes and reserved matters.
Liquidity is an outcome, not an admission promise
Admission creates a venue for trading, not a guarantee of active or stable liquidity. Smaller public companies can have limited research coverage, concentrated registers and wide dealing spreads. An intermittent PISCES event can produce even less frequent price discovery by design. The board should identify the likely buyers, expected free float or available shares and constraints on selling.
Run three cases: planned demand, low demand and no practical liquidity. For each, examine employee expectations, investor relations, future fundraising and valuation signalling. If the transaction only works when a high valuation and strong secondary demand are assumed, the route is not ready for approval.
The companion guide for regional technology companies seeking growth capital without moving to London will distinguish investor access from head-office location. A London listing or platform does not require every operating function to move to the capital.
Readiness begins well before formal preparation
A company should test:
- Audited financial history and timetable.
- Monthly close, forecasting and cash controls.
- Board composition and committee capability.
- Material-contract, litigation and regulatory records.
- Share register, options and beneficial ownership.
- Inside-information and disclosure controls.
- Cybersecurity and data-governance evidence.
- Management capacity for investors and reporting.
- Adviser roles, costs and conflicts.
- A credible use of proceeds or liquidity policy.
Earlier-stage founders using tax-advantaged equity should begin with the SEIS and EIS readiness guide. It addresses a different transaction and should not be confused with public-market readiness.
A board decision matrix
PISCES deserves investigation when the company intends to remain private, the principal need is controlled secondary liquidity and an approved platform can support the desired event. AIM deserves investigation when the company wants a public growth-market admission, can maintain a Nomad relationship and accepts continuing public-company duties. The Main Market deserves investigation when a regulated-market listing and its investor, governance and capital possibilities fit the company's scale and strategy.
Remain private when the objective is vague, systems are immature, management cannot absorb the workload, disclosure would cause disproportionate harm or the likely investor base does not support the transaction. Deferral is a valid decision when accompanied by a readiness plan and a date for reassessment.
Limitations
Market rules, platform availability, adviser practice and investor conditions can change quickly. Transaction costs and investor demand are company-specific and often confidential. This article does not provide legal, tax, investment or listing advice and does not assess any company's suitability. The regulatory position was checked on 13 October 2026 and must be verified immediately before a board decision or publication.
Reporting by Shoreditch Talk




